Bagel Gourmet | Our Story

More Than Just Bagels

We're your neighborhood New Jersey bagel shop, crafting hearty breakfast sandwiches and bagels loaded with specialty cream cheeses in the heart of Galloway. From our belly-busting sandwiches to our seasonal schmears, we're dedicated to serving up the bold, satisfying flavors that make Jersey bagel culture legendary.

One Town, One Standard

Bagel Gourmet took root in Galloway — salt-air South Jersey, where neighbors know your order. Four locations later, that same standard of quality holds.

The Overstuffed Philosophy

Abundance isn't a marketing word here — it's how our signature sandwich is actually built. The Belly Buster is the legend that started the conversation, but every order gets the same treatment: more than you expected, exactly what you wanted.

Cream Cheese Made Here

Rotating seasonal flavors — pumpkin spice, strawberry — sell out fast and get talked about for months. There's no jar in the back; it's made right here in house.

The Cup Beside the Bagel

Pairing with Lacas Coffee — a respected regional roaster out of Philadelphia — wasn't an accident. It's the same logic that drives everything else: if you're going to serve it, serve something worth drinking.

Galloway Voted, Twice

A Patch Readers' Choice poll handed Bagel Gourmet 50% of the vote for best bagels in Galloway — a landslide. Those same regulars are back every Saturday morning.